Updated on: November 2, 2026
Bay Head and Mantoloking are two separate boroughs in Ocean County, New Jersey, side by side on the Barnegat Peninsula, each with its own government, tax rate and beach rules. Buyers browsing waterfront properties here weigh the pair on location, homes, carrying costs, flood rules and beach access.
Key Takeaway
Bay Head and Mantoloking are neighboring but separate boroughs. Bay Head has a walkable business district and its own train station. Mantoloking is almost entirely residential, with errands run in nearby towns. Both rank among the shore's highest-priced markets, both sit largely in flood zones with elevation rules, and they handle beach access differently. Check the access rules and the flood requirements before choosing a house.
Who This Guide Is For
Buyers deciding between a primary or second home in Bay Head or Mantoloking who want the practical differences, from location and price to beach access and flood rules.
Bay Head vs Mantoloking at a Glance
- Two separate Ocean County boroughs; Mantoloking is not part of Brick Township.
- Both are among the Jersey Shore's highest-priced home markets.
- Low tax rates, but high assessments still produce large annual bills.
- Rebuilt or substantially improved homes must meet flood elevation rules.
- Mantoloking badges: required ages 13 and up, third Saturday in June to Labor Day.
Where Bay Head and Mantoloking Are and How They Relate
The New Jersey Legislature incorporated Mantoloking as a borough on April 10, 1911, from portions of Brick Township. That made it a municipality separate from Brick.
Bay Head borders Point Pleasant and Point Pleasant Beach to the north, across the Manasquan River and Beaver Dam Creek area. Mantoloking lies to its south, and Brick Township forms its bay side. Mantoloking borders Bay Head to the north, Point Pleasant to the northwest and a barrier-island section of Brick Township to the south. That section holds Brick's oceanfront beaches. It does not connect to Brick's mainland, so you can reach it only by driving through Mantoloking.
- Population and size: Bay Head had 930 residents in the 2020 census on 0.59 square miles of land, plus 0.12 square miles of water. Mantoloking had 331 residents on 0.39 square miles of land, plus 0.25 square miles of water.
- Train access: Bay Head station is the southern end of NJ Transit's North Jersey Coast Line. Off-peak trains are mostly diesel shuttles connecting at Long Branch for New York Penn Station. Since May 2015, a few rush-hour express trains have run directly to Penn Station.
- Road access: The Mantoloking Bridge crosses Barnegat Bay to Brick Township on the mainland, and Bay Head connects north into Point Pleasant Beach.
Home Prices and Housing: Bay Head vs Mantoloking
Bay Head is expensive by any measure, and Mantoloking prices run in the same tier. Few homes change hands in either town in a given year, so timing matters. When the right house lists, buyers need financing and inspections lined up.
Bay Head's housing stock is older Shingle-style and Victorian homes, many with wrap-around porches and cedar shakes. They sit on a village street grid shaped in part by the early Bay Head-Mantoloking Land Company.
Mantoloking has larger oceanfront and bayfront lots, and many of its homes were rebuilt after Hurricane Sandy to newer coastal construction standards. In both towns, oceanfront and bayfront homes sit at the top of the price range.
Property Taxes and Coastal Living Costs
Taxes and flood insurance are the two big carrying costs when comparing these luxury markets. Both boroughs have low tax rates by New Jersey standards, but a low rate on a very high assessment still produces a large bill. An oceanfront lot will carry a higher bill than a house set back from the water. Bay Head's bill is the assessed value times the general tax rate, and an owner who thinks the assessment is too high can appeal it.
Flood insurance depends partly on each borough's standing in FEMA's Community Rating System. In FEMA's 2013 ratings, Bay Head was a Class 6 community, worth a 20% discount on National Flood Insurance Program premiums in high-risk zones. Mantoloking was Class 5, worth 25%, one of the highest ratings in the state at the time. Both boroughs remained on FEMA's list of participating communities as of April 2022. Get a flood insurance quote on the specific house before signing a contract.
Public Safety and Storm Preparedness
Each borough has its own police, and the objective safety metrics of an area are published every year and worth reviewing before you buy.
Flood and storm risk affects more of the buying decision, because it controls what you can build and how much it costs to insure. Much of both towns lies in FEMA flood zones. There, new or substantially improved homes must be built to the base flood elevation plus any extra height the state and borough require. Raising or rebuilding an older home triggers that standard. Anyone planning a house raise should confirm the required elevation for the lot with the borough's construction office before pricing the work.
Shore protection has grown since Sandy:
- Steel wall: New Jersey DEP drove a roughly four-mile steel sheet-pile wall along Mantoloking and into Brick and Bay Head. It is topped at the FEMA 100-year storm level and designed to last about 75 years. The $23.8 million wall was substantially finished in November 2014.
- Beach and dune: The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers then built an engineered beach and dune over the wall along a 14-mile stretch from Bay Head south to Ortley Beach.
- Completion: Mantoloking's beachfill was finished in December 2018. Sand burying the rock revetment at Bay Head's Johnson Avenue site was completed in July 2019.
New Jersey's Flood Risk Notification Law (N.J.S.A. 56:8-19.2) has been in effect since March 20, 2024. Before you are bound by a contract, every seller must disclose:
- whether the property is in FEMA's Special Flood Hazard Area or Moderate Risk Flood Hazard Area;
- whether federal law requires flood insurance on the property, and whether flood insurance is in place;
- any flood risks the seller knows about.
For storm alerts, sign up with each borough's office of emergency management through its official website.
Daily Life and Amenities in Each Town
Each town caters to a different kind of ordinary day.
Bay Head's business district centers on Bridge Avenue, with some businesses on Main Avenue. It holds art galleries, boutiques, antique shops, food and specialty stores, outdoor cafés and restaurants. You can walk from most homes to the shops, the beach and the train station. Twilight Lake, a tidal lake that feeds Bay Head Harbor and Barnegat Bay, is used for kayaking, paddleboarding and catching crabs, catfish and white perch. Buyers evaluating the borough often consider the daily realities of living in Bay Head, NJ.
Mantoloking is almost entirely residential, with quiet streets running between the ocean and the bay. Groceries, dining and other errands happen in neighboring towns such as Bay Head, Point Pleasant Beach and Brick across the Mantoloking Bridge.
Boardwalk rides, arcades and nightlife are a short drive away in Point Pleasant Beach.
Beaches and Bay Access: Bay Head vs Mantoloking
The two boroughs control the sand in different ways, which matters for anyone hosting guests or renting.
In Bay Head, access to the ocean beaches is managed by the local improvement association and requires a beach badge. Check eligibility and the current season badge price with the association before you buy or rent.
Mantoloking provides public access through ramps and walkways and has one public beach and two private beaches.
- Access points: Public access runs from Mathis Place through Herbert Street. It uses four walkways on East Avenue, one on Lyman Street and one on Ocean Avenue, all on the Bay Head side of town.
- Badge rules: Badges are required for anyone over 12 from the third Saturday in June through Labor Day, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m.
- 2026 prices: Season badges sold for $130 by Memorial Day, $145 after, and daily badges for $15, at trailers at Downer Avenue and Lyman Street.
- Parking: Some streets allow no parking at any time. The shoulder between Lyman and Herbert Streets is open in daylight hours under the Army Corps project's public-access terms.
A renter or houseguest in either town needs their own badge during badge season.
On the bay side, Ocean County's Mantoloking Bridge Fishing Pier County Park sits on the Brick side of the bridge. It has:
- a 70-foot fishing and crabbing pier;
- two bait-cutting and fish-cleaning stations;
- a boardwalk, lighted paths and picnic areas;
- a car-top boat launch for kayaks and paddleboards.
Bay Head Yacht Club, a private club at 111 Metcalfe Street, sits at the northernmost point of Barnegat Bay. Larger boats are often kept at marinas toward the Manasquan Inlet and Brielle.
Bay Head or Mantoloking: Which Fits Your Plans?
- Walkability or quiet: Bay Head puts dinner within walking distance of most homes. Mantoloking is quieter, with errands run in nearby towns.
- Oceanfront or bayfront: Oceanfront homes carry the highest prices and the highest flood exposure. Weigh the elevation and insurance costs above before choosing a side of the peninsula.
- Primary or second home: A year-round commuter benefits from Bay Head's rail connection. A second-home owner should check how each borough's badge rules work for visiting family and guests.
I always recommend scheduling a tour of homes for sale in Bay Head and exploring Mantoloking luxury listings to see which borough truly aligns with your real estate goals. Contact Ed to tour homes in both towns.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I Rent Out a Home in Bay Head or Mantoloking?
Bay Head prohibits rentals of less than seven days, and a rental of seven days to 12 months needs a short-term certificate of occupancy every calendar year. In Mantoloking, check the borough's rental rules before listing.
Which Schools Serve Bay Head and Mantoloking?
Neither borough runs a full elementary-through-high-school system on its own, so confirm the current schools for a specific address with the borough or the New Jersey Department of Education before you buy.
Can You Buy Alcohol in Bay Head or Mantoloking?
Bay Head is a dry town, so beer, wine and liquor are bought in neighboring towns; ask a restaurant whether you can bring your own bottle. Check with Mantoloking borough hall on its rules.
Are There Hotels in Mantoloking or Bay Head?
Bay Head has several hotels and bed-and-breakfast inns near its business district. Mantoloking has none of its own, so buyers touring homes there usually stay in Bay Head or nearby Point Pleasant Beach.
What Is the Weather Like in Mantoloking and Bay Head Through the Year?
The area has warm summers and cold winters typical of the central New Jersey coast. For monthly temperature normals, use NOAA's climate data for the nearest coastal station.







