We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience and deliver our services. By continuing to visit this site, you agree to our use of cookies.More info
Suzie and Ed, Diane Turton RealtorsSuzie and Ed, Diane Turton Realtors
    Ask Us Anything
    Follow us

    Who We Are

    • Who We Are
    • Success Stories & Testimonials
    • Contact Us
    • Market Updates

    Who We Serve

    • The Buyer Experience
    • Featured Listings
    • Search Homes for Sale
    • Bay Head Homes for Sale
    • Mantoloking Homes for Sale

    Suzie and Ed, Diane Turton Realtors

    88 Bridge Ave., Bay Head, NJ 08742

    • 732-691-4477
    • [email protected]
    Bay Head and Mantoloking Market

    Bay Head, NJ vs Point Pleasant, NJ: Comparing Two Neighboring Ocean County Towns

    Bay Head is a small oceanfront borough at the head of Barnegat Bay, while Point Pleasant is the larger mainland borough...

    • Ed O'Malley
    • April 7th, 2026
    • 9 min read
    Featured Image

     

    Bay Head is a small oceanfront borough at the head of Barnegat Bay, while Point Pleasant is the larger mainland borough next door on the Manasquan River and Barnegat Bay, and the two differ most in home prices, water access and town size.

    Key Takeaway

    Bay Head is a very small oceanfront borough of mostly older single-family homes with badge-access ocean beaches and a far higher median price. Point Pleasant Borough is a larger mainland town on the Manasquan River, Barnegat Bay and the canal, with lagoon and inland homes at a lower price point and its own school district. Point Pleasant Beach, home of the boardwalk, is a separate town.

    Who This Guide Is For

    Buyers deciding between a home in Bay Head and one in Point Pleasant Borough.

    Bay Head vs Point Pleasant at a Glance

    • Median home values: Bay Head $4.7M to $5.8M, Borough $716,000 to $986,000.
    • Effective tax rates: Bay Head 0.68% to 0.90%, Borough 1.50% to 2.18%.
    • 2026 Bay Head badges: $120 seasonal; Borough residents swim at river beaches.
    • Bay Head K-8 feeds Point Pleasant Beach High; Borough has own district.
    • Bridge Avenue links the towns; Bay Head station ends the line.

    Point Pleasant vs. Point Pleasant Beach: Where Each Town Sits

    Point Pleasant (the Borough) and Point Pleasant Beach are two separate Ocean County municipalities, each with its own borough council and its own school district. Jenkinson's Boardwalk, the arcades and the ocean beaches are in Point Pleasant Beach, the town just east of the Borough, so choosing between Bay Head vs Point Pleasant Beach means choosing between a boardwalk town and a village.

    On a map, Bay Head sits at the north end of the barrier peninsula at the head of Barnegat Bay, with the ocean on one side and the bay on the other. Route 35 (Main Avenue) runs through it between Point Pleasant Beach to the north and Mantoloking to the south. Point Pleasant Borough lies on the mainland to the west, along the Manasquan River, Barnegat Bay and the Point Pleasant Canal. Both towns are in Ocean County.

    Bridge Avenue (County Road 632) runs through the center of Bay Head and connects west to Point Pleasant Borough and Brick Township. Bay Head station, at Osborne Avenue and Birch Place, is the southern terminus of NJ Transit's North Jersey Coast Line. Before buying for a rail commute, check current train schedules and station parking rules there.

    Vibe and Lifestyle: Oceanfront Village vs. Mainland Borough

    Bay Head is a very small oceanfront village: 0.71 square miles in total, 0.59 of it land, with a 2020 Census population of 930. Its streets are lined with Victorian architecture, the center is compact enough to cross on foot, and there is no boardwalk or amusement strip.

    Point Pleasant Borough covers 3.49 square miles of land and had a 2020 Census population of 18,941, about twenty times Bay Head's count. Residential streets spread across the town and run down to river, bay and canal waterfront, and the commercial roads keep businesses open through the year.

    Real Estate Market Comparison: Bay Head vs Point Pleasant

    Bay Head's housing is almost entirely detached single-family houses on oceanfront, bayfront and village streets, with few condominiums, and many of them are older homes. Because so many are seasonal second homes, few come up for sale and inventory is tight. Point Pleasant Borough's housing runs from lagoon, riverfront and canal-front homes to inland neighborhoods, with a mix of coastal cottages, new construction and traditional suburban houses.

    Median home values in Bay Head have ranged from about $4.7M to $5.8M, compared with roughly $716,000 to $986,000 in Point Pleasant Borough. A typical Bay Head home costs roughly five to eight times a typical Borough home. A budget built around the Borough median will not reach Bay Head's usual price range, but the same budget opens up waterfront and inland choices in the Borough.

    Bay Head housing market trends shift from month to month, so check recent sales in both towns before setting an offer.

    Cost of Living and Property Taxes

    • Bay Head: effective property tax rate of about 0.68% to 0.90%, with annual bills that often exceed $30,000.
    • Point Pleasant Borough: effective rate of about 1.50% to 2.18%, closer to the state average.

    Bay Head's lower rate applies to a far higher home value, so it still produces the larger bill. Owners who believe an assessment is too high can file a Bay Head property tax appeal.

    Flood insurance, elevation requirements and salt-air maintenance add to the ongoing costs of living in Ocean County in both towns, especially for waterfront homes. Before you make an offer, ask whether the house has already been raised and what its flood insurance costs.

    Beaches, Water Access, Dining and Shopping

    Swimming is the clearest split between the towns. Bay Head's guarded ocean beaches are run by the Bay Head Improvement Association (B.H.I.A.), not the borough government, and all of them are open to the public. For the 2026 season, badges are required from June 20 through Labor Day. A full seasonal badge costs $120, a half-season badge $65 and a daily pass $15.

    Point Pleasant Borough has no ocean beach of its own. It runs two bathing beaches on the Manasquan River:

    • Maxson Avenue Beach: next to Riverfront Park, with a playground, fishing pier and accessible walkway.
    • River Avenue Beach: one block west, with a large swimming area and picnic area.

    Both charge admission in season and have lifeguards, and swimming is not allowed when lifeguards are not present. The nearest ocean beaches are in neighboring Point Pleasant Beach.

    Boating favors the Borough. It has a municipal ramp on the Manasquan River at the foot of Curtis Avenue, open to Point Pleasant residents only. It also has a concrete and sand ramp on Barnegat Bay at the foot of Bay Avenue with adequate water at low tide. The state's Point Pleasant Canal Fishing Access site adds a public ramp on the canal. Bay Head's water access is its bayfront on Barnegat Bay.

    For dining and shopping, Bay Head's commercial center along Bridge Avenue and Lake Avenue has boutique shops, bakeries and cafes. Point Pleasant Borough's businesses spread along larger commercial roads.

    Schools and Parks

    • Bay Head: the Bay Head School District runs a smaller, localized elementary school setup, a single K-8 school with 132 students. High school students attend Point Pleasant Beach High School for grades 9 to 12 under a sending relationship with the Point Pleasant Beach School District.
    • Point Pleasant Borough: the Point Pleasant School District operates Nellie F. Bennett Elementary School, Ocean Road Elementary School, Memorial Middle School and Point Pleasant Borough High School for grades 9 to 12.

    For parks, the Borough has Riverfront Park beside Maxson Avenue Beach. In Bay Head, the beaches and Twilight Lake serve as the main open space.

    Which Town Should You Choose?

    • Water: Bay Head puts you near guarded ocean beaches. The Borough puts you on river, bay and canal water with municipal and state boat ramps.
    • Housing: Bay Head offers mostly older single-family village homes. The Borough offers lagoon, riverfront and inland neighborhoods.
    • Budget: the price and tax gaps covered above are large, so set your budget first and the list of homes narrows quickly.
    • Daily life: Bay Head's village center is small and seasonal, while the Borough's commercial roads serve daily needs all year.
    • Commuting: for rail commuters, Bay Head's in-town station is a practical advantage

    Suzie & Ed can tour homes in both towns with you. If you own in either town, get your home's value: our custom reports include accurate and up-to-date information. Request a home value report.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is Point Pleasant a Dry Town?

    No. Point Pleasant Borough issues plenary retail consumption licenses for bars and restaurants and also regulates BYOB establishments. Bay Head is the dry one: it is known as a borough with no licensed bars, restaurants or liquor stores, and buyers who want certainty can confirm with the Borough Clerk.

    Do Bay Head and Point Pleasant Share a ZIP Code?

    Yes. Bay Head, Point Pleasant Borough and Point Pleasant Beach all use ZIP code 08742, and the Postal Service's preferred city name for it is Point Pleasant Beach. A mailing address can read "Point Pleasant" or "Point Pleasant Beach" even when the property sits in Bay Head or the Borough, so confirm the municipality on the tax record.

    Is Bay Head, NJ a Good Place to Live?

    It is a walkable village with ocean beaches and a train station in town. Living in Bay Head year-round means a quieter village once the beach season ends.

    Is Bay Head, NJ an Affluent Town?

    By home values, yes. Bay Head's median home value is among the highest at the Jersey Shore.

    What Is the Prettiest Town on the Jersey Shore?

    No single town holds that title. Bay Head draws praise for its Victorian architecture and shoreline, while Point Pleasant Borough offers views along the Manasquan River and bay waterfront.

    Sources

    • Point Pleasant, New Jersey (Wikipedia)
    • Bay Head, New Jersey (Wikipedia)
    • Bay Head Self-Reliance Policy Report, NJ Department of Community Affairs
    • Bay Head Station (Wikipedia)
    • Point Pleasant Borough QuickFacts, U.S. Census Bureau
    • Beach Information, Borough of Bay Head
    • Beach Rules, Borough of Point Pleasant
    • Beaches, Borough of Point Pleasant Recreation
    • Boat Ramp Guide, NJ Division of Fish and Wildlife
    • Bay Head School District
    • Bay Head Code, Chapter 66: Alcoholic Beverages
    Author Photo
    About the author

    Ed O'Malley

    732.779.5088
    As a life-long, year-round resident of the Bay Head and Mantoloking area, Ed combines his outstanding local knowledge and connections with his more than 24 years’ real estate experience to work for every client. His commitment to service is of the highest caliber. He joined Diane Turton, Realtors in August 2003, and in 2004, formed a very successful partnership with Suzie Van Schoick. Their success as a team continues to this day. Most recently Suzie and Ed were recognized as the Real Estate Team with the Most Closed Residential Single Family Sales in Bay Head and Mantoloking in 2020* (*Based on MORR MLS Residential Single Family Closed Sales in Bay Head and Mantoloking for 2020). Recent awards can be found here. Ed is an avid photographer, and is also a licensed drone pilot. To further support his clients, Ed has earned the following designations: e-PRO and Resort and Second-Home Property Specialist (RSPS) certifications in order to better serve their clients with the latest information and technology (2014); Seller Representation Specialist (SRS) designation, in order to better counsel and represent their seller clients (2016); and in 2017, Ed earned his Certified Residential Specialist (CRS), a hallmark of both experience and education. Ed has also earned his ABR (Accredited Buyers' Representative), RENE (Real Estate Negotiation Expert), and GREEN ( NAR's designation for education regarding marketing and understanding green properties [smart features, energy efficiency, and other environmentally aware practices.] A complete listing of his certifications and designations can be found here. Ed graduated from Kenyon College with a Bachelor of Arts in Biology in 1997. While still a student at Kenyon, Ed founded his consulting company, Osprey Technology Consulting. His continuing involvement with his consulting clients complements his experience as a realtor in the Bay Head area. Ed is also an alumnus of St. George’s School in Middletown, RI. When not working, Ed is an avid sailor, skier, and fisherman, vacationing in Florida and Vermont. He is also an active member of Mantoloking Yacht Club and Manasquan River Golf Club. In addition, he also gives his time as a volunteer and board member of Save Barnegat Bay (NJ), a volunteer for the Mt. Washington Observatory (NH), and a consultant to the Mantoloking Environmental Commission. Ed is also a member of the Point Pleasant Beach Rotary, the Bay Head Business Association, and is a member of the Algonquin Theatre Board of Directors.

    Similar posts like this

    Information and Education

    Bay Head Is Still Open: Your Fall Guide to Local Hours

    Read more
    Bay Head and Mantoloking Market

    Is Mantoloking, NJ Safe? Flood Risk and Crime Facts

    In Mantoloking, the safety questions that change what a buyer pays aren't about crime figures. They're about flood and storm...

    Read more
    Bay Head and Mantoloking Market

    Mantoloking, NJ vs. Jersey Shore: Costs and Market Pace

    Mantoloking is a quiet, residential barrier-island borough with no boardwalk, no amusement rides, and no strip of restaurants....

    Read more
    Suzie and Ed, Diane Turton Realtors

    Suzanne B. Van Schoick and Edwin C. O'Malley, Diane Turton, Realtors

    Each office Independently Owned and Operated

    88 Bridge Ave., Bay Head, NJ 08742

    Suzanne B. Van Schoick and Edwin C. O'Malley, Diane Turton, Realtors

    Each office Independently Owned and Operated

    88 Bridge Ave., Bay Head, NJ 08742

    732-691-4477
    [email protected]

    Resources

    • Search for Homes
    • Buyers
    • Sellers
    • Get Your Home's Value
    • Read Our Blog
    • Schedule a Call
    • Reviews
    Join Our Email List:

    *We respect your inbox. We only send interesting and relevant emails.

    Suzanne B. Van Schoick and Edwin C. O'Malley, Diane Turton, Realtors © 2026

    Privacy Policy
    Powered by